QUESTION TEXT: Everyone sitting in the waiting room of the school’s…
QUESTION TYPE: Must be True
FACTS:
- A few people are in the waiting room.
- Everyone in the waiting room signed up for a beginner’s clinic.
- Therefore they aren’t experts.
ANALYSIS: This is pretty simple. John, Mary and Theresa aren’t expert tennis players.
___________
- This goes too far. They might have played tennis. They just aren’t experts.
- They might have registered for other clinics as well. The stimulus didn’t say anything about this.
- The stimulus says everyone in the waiting room registered. But it didn’t say that only the people in the waiting room registered.
- The stimulus didn’t say there were no other people in the waiting room.
- CORRECT. This has to be true, since John and Theresa registered for a beginner’s clinic.
Recap: The question begins with “Everyone sitting in the waiting room of the school’s”. It is a Must be True question. Learn how to master LSAT MBT questions on the LSAT Logical Reasoning question types page.
Member [email protected] says
Hey Graeme,
The passage starts by saying “Everyone in the waiting room at 9am just registered for the tennis clinic”. The answer B goes on to mirror this (in my view). Is this wrong because we must answer what is also true rather than what is already true?
Best regards,
Amaresh
Tutor Aaminah_LSATHacks says
Hi Amaresh,
That’s not why B is wrong. B says that everyone sitting there registered ONLY for a beginners tennis clinic. All we know is that they had registered for the tennis clinic, but there’s no textual support that tennis is the only clinic they registered for. So B assumes something that the stimulus does not say. Hope that helps!