LR Question 1 Explanation, by LSATHacks
QUESTION TEXT: The quantity and type of pollution that entered the…
QUESTION TYPE: Strengthen
CONCLUSION: We can't be certain enough to justify punishing the auto repair shop.
REASONING: There is some evidence that the auto shop is responsible for the pollution. But the penalty is very severe.
ANALYSIS: We're trying to judge whether the auto shop is responsible: should we convict them, or not? The argument says that stronger evidence is needed, because the penalty is harsh.
We need a principle that says this is correct. So the right answer will say that we should require strong evidence in order to impose harsh punishments. Principle questions are about what 'should' happen.
Answers B, C and E are about how to set a penalty for a crime. That's irrelevant. The penalty for this crime is already set.
A note on logical errors: did you feel that the auto shop was at fault? There's very little proof. 'Some' evidence 'suggests' the auto body shop is guilty. If you instantly decided the auto body shop was guilty, then that's a mental error you need to eliminate.
___________
- CORRECT. This matches what the stimulus said. The penalty is severe, so this answer tells us that we should wait for stronger evidence.
- This tells us how severely you ought to punish crimes. But the stimulus was about whether we could conclude that the auto shop was guilty.
- Same as B. This is about how to set the penalty for a crime. But we are trying to decide whether the auto shop is guilty. The penalty is already set.
- No one has confessed. This is irrelevant. Admission of guilt is just a factor that might let us avoiding debating whether we have enough evidence to convict the auto body shop.
- This tells you how to set a penalty. It doesn't tell you how to know whether someone is guilty.
Hi, I'm Graeme Blake
Founder of LSAThacks; I scored a 177 on the LSAT.
I created the LSAT Mastery Seminars, which are part of the Ultimate LSAT Prep Bundle
If you like the explanations you're reading I'm 100% confident you'll enjoy the courses. Satisfaction guaranteed.
---------
Updates:
For updates, sign up for my email list. I update whenever I have new posts.
After spending a thousand dollars on an LSAT course, I’ve learned more from these free explanations than I have with my course. I can only imagine the miracles the purchased courses offer. I wish I would have found you sooner. Thank you for providing this for free to those of us who cannot fork out thousands! I found myself unable to afford a prep class the first time around. The second time around, I thought I did my research. However, I am very disappointed. You are the reason I am understanding the concepts so thank you! You speak the English that is needed for those of us that do not grasp the concepts as easily!
Thank you!! :) That’s very kind, and I’m glad the site is helping you so much.