DISCUSSION: You might think that the point of the passage is to compare two theories of mirrors. But the field-of-sight theory is only mentioned to establish that we have a pretty good explanation of mirrors. After the first paragraph, the field-of-sight theory is not mentioned again.
Instead, the rest of the passage discussed the front-to-back theory. The main point of the passage is that the front-to-back theory is not satisfactory. This is because it doesn’t consider what happens when we look into mirrors (last two sentences of para. 4).
___________
- The passage doesn’t give any evidence against the field-of-sight theory. It appears the author agrees that this theory is correct.
- This is a tempting answer, but the front-to-back theory is not based on empirical evidence. We use our mental constructs to imagine the front-to-back theory (the second sentence of paragraph 3), but these constructs are contrary to fact (paragraph 3). The front-to-back explanation is based on a false idea.
- Second-to-last sentence of paragraph 4 did mention two necessary conditions for an explanation of mirrors, but this is not the same as listing difficulties that need to be overcome. A difficulty is a specific obstacle that needs to be removed, for instance “we need to construct a physically perfect mirror” or “we need to figure out a way to measure light entering a mirror”.
- CORRECT. Paragraphs 2-4 are dedicated to showing why the front-to-back theory is inadequate. See the passage analysis section and the discussion above for more details.
- The passage does explain why the front-to-back theory is accepted. But it is not because of theoretical support. Instead, the front-to-back theory receives support for two reasons:
1. The front-to-back explanation seems natural to us, due to the way we imagine mirrors (paragraph 3)
2. Scientists like to separate the observer from the phenomenon (first sentence of paragraph 4)
Want a free Reading Comp lesson?
Get a free sample of the Reading Comprehension Mastery Seminar. Learn tips for solving RC questions
Leave a Reply