We must be in scenario 3 if both grammars are on the same shelf. It’s the only way to fit F + H + a novel (in this case, Vonnegut.) Remember, F always has to go with a novel.
Here’s scenario 3 again, with H on the third shelf:
We can see A is wrong because no monographs can be on the third shelf.
B is wrong because the first shelf has to have a monograph on it.
C is wrong because V has to be on the third shelf.
D is wrong because F has to be on the third shelf. If we put F on the second, there would be no room to fit H as well as a novel.
E is CORRECT. Either S or P can be on the first shelf.
Want a free Logic Games lesson?
Get a free sample of the Logic Games Mastery Seminar. Learn tips for going faster at logic games