LSATHacks

The Explanations That Should Have Come With The LSAT

  • LSAT Explanations
  • Tutoring
  • Mastery Courses
  • Login
  •   Cart
LSAT Explanations › Preptest 31 › Logical Reasoning 1 › Question 12

LSAT 31, Logical Reasoning I, Q12, LSATHacks

LSAT 31 Explanations

LR Question 12 Explanation, by LSATHacks

QUESTION TEXT: Some biologists believe that the capacity for flight first…

QUESTION TYPE: Role in Argument

ARGUMENTS:

  1. One group of scientists argues that marine reptiles were the first to fly. These scientists claimed that feathers obviously developed from scales.
  2. A second group correctly rejects this idea. They point out that non-marine reptiles also have scales and that bats (which can fly) have no scales.
  3. A third group believes that flight developed in tree-dwelling reptiles. They reject the claim that land reptiles might have developed wings. They claim it’s more likely that tree reptiles developed wings to jump between trees. 

ANALYSIS: This question has a lot of words. We can focus on the second group of scientists. They point out that non-marine reptiles have scales. 

The first group claimed that the fact that marine reptiles had scales meant that they must have been the first fliers. They were assuming that only marine reptiles had scales. But if other animals such as non-marine reptiles had scales then this argument falls apart. 

The claim serves as evidence to show that the first group is wrong. 

___________

  1. CORRECT. It directly weakens the claim. 
  2. No, the scientists were reacting to the claim of the first group. The first group argued that flight arose in marine reptiles.
  3. Same as B. The claim was used against scientists who believed that marine reptiles were the first to fly.
  4. Same as B and C. 
  5. No, it doesn’t corroborate the observation. If I showed you an Iguana would you cry out: “this must mean that bats can fly!”? That would be silly.

Previous Question
PT 31 /  PT 113
Next Question

More Resources for Role in Argument Questions

  • Intro Course lesson: This intro course lesson covers Role in Argument questions.
  • Mastery Seminar lesson: This LR Mastery seminar lesson covers role in argument questions.
Quick Jump PT Section Que

Free Five Part LSAT Email Course

Hi, I'm Graeme Blake

I scored a 177 on the LSAT. I founded LSATHacks and created the LSAT Mastery Seminars to help students succeed.

I’ve personally written explanations for 5,000+ LSAT questions. If you find these explanations helpful, you'll definitely like our courses.

Join my email list for LSAT study tips and resources.

Comments

  1. Member Aden says

    July 28, 2021 at 3:20 pm

    The way you wrote that analysis makes it seem like you just looked at the answer and then wrote it. You didn’t say anything about how we should know to focus on the other biologists, you just say to do it.

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Free LSAT Email Course

My best LSAT tips, straight to your inbox


Increase Your Score

LSATHacks Ultimate Bundle

Get the LSATHacks Mastery seminars, the Intro Course, the LSATHacks Mastery Toolkit and a Strategy Call. All for only $499, satisfaction guaranteed.

Buy now

Testimonials

Your emails are tremendously helpful. - Matt

Thanks for the tips! They were very helpful, and even make you feel like you studied a bit. Great insight and would love more! - Haj

Dear Graeme: MUCH MORE PLEASE!! Your explanations are very clear, and you give equal importance to why answers are WRONG, as well as why THE ANSWER is right!! Very well done. Thank you for all your efforts - Tom

These have been awesome. More please!!! - Caillie

The course was immensely helpful and has eased my nerves a lot. - Lovlean

Resources

  • Articles
  • Blog
  • Free Email Course
  • LSAT Preptest Converter

About LSATHacks

  • About/Contact
  • Courses
  • Free Trial
  • FAQ/Legal

Community

  • Discord
  • Social Media
  • Webinars
Disclaimer: Use of this site requires official LSAT preptests; the explanations are of no use without the preptests. If you do not have the accompanying preptests, you can find them here: LSAT preptests
LSAT is copyright of LSAC. LSAC does not review or endorse specific test preparation materials or services and has not reviewed this site.

© Copyright 2025 LSATHacks. All Rights Reserved. | FAQ/Legal