QUESTION TEXT: Grasses and woody plants are planted on…
QUESTION TYPE: Flawed Reasoning
CONCLUSION: We can prevent erosion by having predators hunt rats.
REASONING: There are two problems that occur when we plant grass and woody plants to prevent erosion.
First, rats come and eat the woody plants that prevent erosion. Second, grass clippings cause woody plants’ roots to die, and this lead to erosion.
ANALYSIS: The argument tells us two problems that will lead to erosion. Then it gives us a solution to solve one of the two problems.
The author forgot that we need to do something about the smothered roots.
___________
- Which two events? We’re not told that any
co-occur.Also, there are some events that clearly do cause other events. Grass clippings smother roots, and attract rats, for example.
- All the facts are general. The argument doesn’t mention any particular dirt embankments.
- This isn’t a circular argument. The argument is even half-good: predators might eliminate rats, at least.
- The argument never said predators are the only solution.
- CORRECT. Predators will get rid of the rats, but they won’t stop the roots from rotting. The author’s solution is incomplete.
Free Logical Reasoning lesson
Get a free sample of the Logical Reasoning Mastery Seminar. Learn tips for solving LR questions
Leave a Reply